Review: good for the price Beauty product: 4 Stars
I got these on sale - black for myself and navy & grey for my daughter. Goes on easy, comes off without trouble, colors are nice but it doesn't stay really well - just average. But it does work and stay at least as well as other more expensive brands I've tried, so that's not a huge problem. They navy is a nice balance between dark and bright, just blue enough to add a dash of color (and not as severe as black) but not so much as to distract from the overall look or color of your eyes.
Review: not very good Beauty product: 2 Stars
I bought this for the convenience of not having to sharpen. I have a similar product from Clinique, but this pales in comparison. This eyeliner was too dry. The color didn't apply well so it wasn't dark enough. Even if I use more pressure, it results don't improve. Liquid eyeliner is better than this. Otherwise, if you opt for a pencil, get the kind that you have to sharpen.