I bought a black one and loved it so much that I got a blue and grey also (to match my many different contacts). It does smudge slightly, but you just have to learn to work with it. I've found that if I put a mild touch under my eye and then put a heavy line above that within 20 minutes it will have a good look to it. This eye liner has staying power, you have to try to remove it to get it to come off, it won't wear over time!
Have this in the Black shade. It works well I guess. I just find that it smears a lot. But the color is nice and dark, so I would get it if you don't mind it smearing a little here and there.
Review: Easy to use Beauty product: 5 Stars
This eyeliner is great. It glides over the eyelid and stays put all day. It's also hassle free because instead of having to worry with sharpening a pencil, you just twist it.
Review: Finally the perfect eyeliner Beauty product: 5 Stars
Slides on smoothly and looks divine. You can make the lines as think or as thin as you want and smoky eyes are easy with this. The packaging is small and classy. There no need to sharpen the eyeliner ever you just twist up more.
Review: No raccoon eyes! Beauty product: 5 Stars
I was looking for a liner that would last all day, not "bleed" under eye and did not look harsh (over 40 eyes!)...this is the ticket! I want every shade!