I love this product. I purchased the black and it is rich and goes on well. It stays on until I take it off with my cleanser at night. It gives my eyes some drama and "pop".
I highly recommend the product.
Review: Cake eye liner Beauty product: 3 Stars
I was so happy to find this product. I am a former user of Clinique cake eye liner. I liked the way it went on and looked. However, I found that it flaked during the day. I was disappointed in that. It is the best I've tried since Clinique stopped making their cake eye liner.
Review: lydiagirl41 Beauty product: 4 Stars
I really like the cake eyeliner. I use it with the Bare Essentials Liquid stayon which really keeps my eyeliner on all day. Both are great products.
Review: Cake eyeliner Beauty product: 5 Stars
I absolutely love the Ben Nye cake eyeliner. It stays on until I remove it at night. It doesn't run like liquid eyeliners. I use to use Clinque but they quit making it and it was pretty expensive. I read the reviews about the Ben Nye eyeliner and thought I would go ahead a take a chance. So glad I did. Please don't ever discontinue this product.
Review: ALICE COOPER LOOK!! Beauty product: 1 Stars
THAT'S WHAT I GOT. Ran with the least provocation. Extremely disappointed and too cheap to go through the return process.